Episode 1
Anna Borntregger has been dead for 10 years, so when her husband suddenly tells police he murdered her they don't know what to make of his confession
Episode 2
When the body of a 9-year-old boy is found by the side of a rural highway it takes police two years to identify him. The mystery leads police on a chilling odyssey into a secretive community and hot on the trail of an Amish serial killer.
Episode 3
When a young Amish wife is found murdered in her bed, police uncover a dark world they never imagine existed.
Episode 4
Naomi Huyard never strayed far from home, so her sudden vanishing rocks her tight-knit community to it's core. When detectives make an unspeakable discovery, they soon realize there's much more to the story than meets the eye.
Episode 5
When Katie Gingerich is found murdered and disemboweled, even the most hardened police are shocked. A conflict of faith in the strict Amish community could have led to such a brutal act.
Episode 6
When a Mennonite family man is stopped for drunk-driving, no one could predict that it would expose a shocking underbelly of organized crime. Abraham Wiebe risks it all as a central figure in one of the largest criminal cases in Oklahoma history
